Gibraltars Offshore gambling sites on the Internet have revolutionized the sports betting industry

Gibraltars Offshore gambling sites on the Internet have revolutionized the sports betting industry. The offshore betting sites compete for the bettors’ money, and are constantly improving consumer services
Showing posts with label is legally testing decisions made by Judicial Services Commission. Show all posts
Showing posts with label is legally testing decisions made by Judicial Services Commission. Show all posts

Sunday, 10 June 2012

Isaac Marrache, the senior partner of the law firm embroiled in one of Gibraltar’s biggest ever fraud cases, is legally testing decisions made by Judicial Services Commission

Gibraltar’s judicial system could be facing the greatest challenge to its standing and ability to run effectively since the 2007-2008 Schofield affair. Allegations include that, until he was challenged, the Chief Justice Anthony Dudley failed to declare that a defendant was his regular lunching partner and that the body that appoints judges was caught in a loop of possible conflicts of interest or bias.

Isaac Marrache, the senior partner of the law firm embroiled in one of Gibraltar’s biggest ever fraud cases, is legally testing decisions made by Judicial Services Commission (JSC).

Mr Marrache’s action includes challenging the JSC’s decision not to investigate his complaint about the judicial conduct of the Chief Justice. He wants an order to make the JSC do so and suggest that, if this happened, the judge could end up going before a disciplinary tribunal.

And it has emerged that, just days before a hearing for the commencement of the committal proceedings of the criminal case next week, lawyers acting separately for Isaac Marrache’s brother Benjamin have raised concerns that lawyer James Neish, QC, a witness for that case, was also part of the JSC panel that appointed the legendary judge Timothy Workman to hear that case.

Mr Justice Workman has worked in high profile terrorism and criminal cases including rejecting the Russian government’s extradition request for a Chechen leader in London because he feared the defendant might be exposed to the threats of torture or death

The Chronicle understands that although the issue has been raised with the Governor’s office no actual formal objection to the appointment of Mr Justice Workman has been made nor is one likely given his high standing and reputation for independence.

Brothers Benjamin, Solomon and Isaac Marrache together with former employee Leanne Turnbull, are accused of a multi-million pound fraud following the collapse of local law firm Marrache & Co.

There is separate civil litigation concerning the bankruptcy of the firm Marrache & Co.

Judicial review sought

At the heart of the Judicial review sought by Isaac Marrache is Mr Justice Dudley’s alleged failure to recuse himself from the case given his friendship with one of the defendants, Solomon Marrache.

Court documents filed April 25 2012 show that Isaac Marrache’s lawyer Stephen Knafler, QC, is seeking leave for Judicial Review of three key decisions by the JSC: their failure to investigate or determine Mr Marrache’s complaint about the judicial conduct of the Chief Justice in “a procedurally fair and thorough manner”; the JSC’s none consideration of whether, in the light of such a determination, it would be appropriate to refer the case of the Chief Justice to the Governor or to the President of the Court under terms of the Judicial Service Act and; the JSC’s decision to decline to take any of these steps because of its view that if the Chief Justice had erred as alleged this would be something for the Court of Appeal, and therefore not for the JSC itself nor the President of the Court, to consider.

‘Apparent bias’

But the documents also claim that the JSC meeting which took the decision under challenge was attended by the Attorney General Ricky Rhoda, the Stipendiary Magistrate Charles Pitto, and Mr Neish as well as Sir Paul Kennedy, the Deputy Governor Lesley Pallett and former Chief Secretary Richard Garcia.

“The Attorney General, Stipendiary Magistrate Pitto and Mr James Neish QC should have recused themselves on the ground of apparent bias,” says the submission. “Mr James Neish QC is a prosecution witness in the case against the claimant, Stipendiary Magistrate Pitto recused himself from hearing criminal proceedings involving the claimant (Isaac Marrache) and his brothers, on the ground that his wife worked at Marrache &Co and was made redundant prior to the collapse of the firm; the Attorney General headed the prosecuting authority and was a close personal friend of the Chief Justice.”

Events

On December 7 2011 the Mr Justice Dudley stepped back from hearing an application stemming from the collapse of Marrache & Co because of his friendship with Solomon Marrache, one of the firm’s directors. Mr Dudley, sitting as a Court of Appeal judge, had been due to consider an application relating to a bankruptcy case involving Isaac Marrache, Solomon Marrache’s brother.

Although that recusal application related solely to one specific issue in the bankruptcy case – it had no effect on past decisions or parallel cases – Mr Justice Dudley indicated at that time that he would be unlikely to sit in any criminal matters involving the Marrache brothers.

The criminal case is currently still before the Magistrates Court but if the defendants were to be committed for trial this would be in the Supreme Court, where Mr Justice Dudley presides.

Mr Justice Dudley, who once worked for Marrache & Co, said at that hearing in December that the friendship with Solomon Marrache was limited to “reasonably regular” lunches in the company of two other friends, adding that he had not had any contact with him since before the collapse of the firm.

But he acknowledged the concern raised by the lawyers and said he had made arrangements for another Court of Appeal judge to handle the specific application in question.

Complaint

On December 16 2011 Isaac Marrache made a formal complaint to Governor Sir Adrian Johns alleging that the Chief Justice had breached the Gibraltar Code of Judicial Conduct and Ethics by presiding over hearings in criminal and civil litigation without disclosing his friendship Solomon Marrache.

The reply from the Assistant Deputy Governor was that the matter might potentially be considered as part of legal proceedings or in the Court of Appeal and therefore the Governor would not take any action.

After this, in January this year, Isaac Marrache went back to the Governor and the JSC saying that his complaint referred to past matters and that he could not see how it could arise in current or future proceedings. He also argued that the JSC could have investigated the complaint and might have even advised the Governor to refer this to a disciplinary tribunal or issued a warning or reprimand.

The submissions for the Judicial Review indicate that Mr Marrache’s lawyers believe that it is no longer “possible, practicable, sensible or … desirable” to appeal the decisions in question. They argue this on the basis that Isaac “was aware that the Chief Justice lunched on a weekly basis with Mr Solomon Marrache, over a period of many years, but did not raise the matter in the course of any proceedings in which he was involved with a view to asking for more information, or with a view to asking the Chief Justice to recuse himself.”

Magistrate’s Recusal

On April 3 2012 Stipendiary Magistrate Charles Pitto withdrew from hearing the preliminary stage of a multi-million pound fraud case stemming from the collapse of the law firm Marrache & Co.

His decision followed an application by the lawyer representing defendant Benjamin Marrache.

No date has yet been set for application for leave for Judicial Review

link

Related Posts with Thumbnails